To best understand the economy, replace government with self?

The Republican presidential debate on 10 November 2015 did little to enlighten me on how these candidates view the role of American government in the economy.

Ted Cruz, the senator from Texas, shared with us that he intended to eliminate four or five agencies along with a plan for reducing taxes.

Donald Trump, while reiterating the need for a physical wall between the United States and Mexico, also shared with the viewers his plan to cut taxes on the middle class while raising taxes on his wealthier friends.

Just about everyone had a tax plan that they argued would help put more money in the pockets of Americans while businesses, freed from onerous regulations, would be free to spend more on hiring American talent because they would have an incentive to stay in the United States and conduct business.  The rhetoric of tax reduction and reducing the size of government was not surprising last night and quite frankly had me bored by about the 75th minute of the debate.  So bored had I become that I even declared on my personal Facebook page that this debate would be the last political debate that I would ever watch.

Not that the moderators did a poor job. On the contrary, Gerald Seib, Neil Cavuto, and Maria Bartiromo did a very good job keeping the discussion on the economy and, to the relief of Ben Carson, were wise enough not to ask any questions requiring one to recall what they said in high school.

The poor performance was actually delivered by the candidates. None described America’s actual politico-economic system.  They all decided to fall back on the parlor trick of watering down a complex topic of the economy to one of taxes and jobs. Study economic history and you’ll see that the economy has never been just about taxes and, in my opinion, hs not much of anything about jobs.  Whether in Benin, Brazil, Cuba, Ghana, Russia, or the United States, the economy has always been about extarcting and managing resources.  For a nation-state’s economy, it has been specifically about the extraction and management of resources for the benefit of the elite few that lay ultimate claim to or try to exercise authority over resources.  It is the “who” or the “final benefit” that is always left out of the equation.

A discussion about jobs and taxes are nothing more than the red meat politicians throw at the electorate to get a vote.  Jobs and taxes are packaged as a narrative for sale to Joe Six-Pack with the hopes that Joe ascertains enough benefit from the offer. Joe has no idea as to the package’s true cost.  He doesn’t do enough homework because the cost of gathering the information is too much; too time consuming.  It’s easier for him to digest the job projections and go “yeah, yeah” when he hears he may get a 20% reduction in his taxes or get a rebate check of $300 so he can go out and buy a sofa.  Any gains to Joe would be as short term as the aggregate output gains to the nation-state.

Rather than buying into the politician’s definition of the economy, Joe Six-Pack should base a decision on what the economy is by simply looking at himself as an economic unit. To be a successful individual economic unit, Joe will have to first first ascertain his resources, his capital, not from the consumer-based view of a policy paradigm based on jobs and taxes, but from a producer-based paradigm based on having the resources necessary for sustaining myself. Do I have land, minerals, air, sources of energy upon which I can sustain myself? If not, where can I extract these resources? How best do I manage them so that I can sustain myself?

At this point you are probably saying, “Is this guy recommending we go back to the Dark Ages?” No, I’m not. However, the concept of self-reliance should never be abandoned especially if you believe that you are in the best position to make the best economic choices for yourself.

Today’s technology is providing the tools necessary for increased self-reliance.  As renewable energy technology improves, more Americans are opting for supplying their own energy needs. Making more unlicensed spectrum available means using more innovative devices at home that can enhance your productivity or your leisure. Technology can make transportation a resource versus the consumption of a final good. Why buy a car that sits most of the time idle when technology allows you to access transportation on demand?

As much as the Republicans talk about personal and economic freedom, their narrative on the economy boiled down to “this is what we can for you.”  We, government, can reform your taxes rather than freeing you from them. We, government, can create jobs rather than you creating your own commercial value and selling that value on an open market.

The GOP repeated the same mantra as the Democrats. We will continue to monopolize the resources you need to be self-sustaining while sending a little chump change your way.

 

About Alton Drew

Alton Drew brings a straight forward and insightful brand of political market intelligence. Alton Drew graduated from the Florida State University with a Bachelor of Science in economics and political science (1984); a Master of Public Administration (1993); and a Juris Doctor (1999). You can also follow Alton Drew on Twitter @altondrew.
This entry was posted in economics, Economy, Election2016, employment, energy, libertarian, liberty, Political Economy, renewable energy, spectrum and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to To best understand the economy, replace government with self?

  1. kenski2013 says:

    “As much as the Republicans talk about personal and economic freedom, their narrative on the economy boiled down to “this is what we can for you.” We, government, can reform your taxes rather than freeing you from them. We, government, can create jobs rather than you creating your own commercial value and selling that value on an open market.

    The GOP repeated the same mantra as the Democrats. We will continue to monopolize the resources you need to be self-sustaining while sending a little chump change your way.”

    Ironically, the Republicans consistent complain the the Democrats are the tax and spend, giveaway to the poor (and maybe middle class occasionally) party. As you point out, Alton, the Republicans are making claims about what they will give away. It the past it was mostly to businesses and the wealthy. I’m surprised to hear they are offering anyone else anything at all.

    As for:

    “At this point you are probably saying, “Is this guy recommending we go back to the Dark Ages?” No, I’m not. However, the concept of self-reliance should never be abandoned especially if you believe that you are in the best position to make the best economic choices for yourself.”

    I understand and agree that each of us should be as self reliant as possible. That said. the amount of income it takes to live in the USA today, even at a modest level is a lot! Few individuals have the money capital and the human capital (abilities) needed to generate that level of income on their own. It’s necessary to band together and/or work with others to form businesses and create enough wealth and income on which to live. Bringing together people to work together has a kind of multiplier effect in that different people have different skills and abilities of many kinds, and many different kinds of abilities are needed to create a successful business in many situations.

    In my own case, I don’t know how to sell or promote or market myself or anything else very well, but I am good at managing, solving both technical and procedural business problems, and providing great customer service. I worked in various companies who were good at promoting, marketing and selling products and services, but those who performed those functions were not very good at managing, solving both technical and procedural business problems, and providing great customer service. Our working together was good for all of us.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s